How to Interview a Bookkeeper: Finding the Right Fit for Your Business
4 min read
0
Hiring a bookkeeper is more than checking a box on your to‑do list; it’s choosing a financial partner who will support your decision‑making, protect your peace of mind, and help your business grow. The right bookkeeper isn’t just technically competent; they’re aligned with your business needs, communication style, and processes.
This guide walks you through how to interview a bookkeeper with intention, so you can confidently assess skills, personality fit, and process fit and avoid costly mismatches down the road.
Step 1: Get Clear on What You Need First
Before you interview anyone, take time to clarify what you’re actually hiring for. Many frustrating bookkeeping relationships start with unclear expectations.
Ask yourself:
What stage is my business in (startup, growing, established)?
What do I need help with right now versus in 6–12 months?
Do I want ongoing monthly support, cleanup, advisory insight, or all three?
How involved do I want to be in my finances?
Knowing this upfront allows you to evaluate candidates against your priorities, not a generic checklist.
Step 2: Questions to Ask About Skills & Experience
Technical competence is essential, but you don’t need someone who does everything; you need someone who does what you need well.
Core Experience Questions
Consider asking:
What types of businesses do you typically work with?
Do you have experience with businesses similar to mine (industry, size, revenue model)?
Which accounting software do you specialize in?
How do you stay current on bookkeeping best practices and software changes?
Scope & Boundaries
These questions help prevent future misunderstandings:
What services are included in your monthly work?
What is not included and would be billed separately?
How do you handle cleanup or catch‑up work?
Accuracy & Quality Control
To understand how they protect your books:
What is your process for reconciling accounts?
How do you catch and correct errors?
How do you collaborate with CPAs or tax preparers?
You’re listening not just for what they do, but how thoughtfully they do it.
Step 3: Gauge Personality & Communication Fit
A technically skilled bookkeeper who doesn’t communicate well with you can quickly become a source of stress.
Communication Style
Ask questions like:
How do you typically communicate with clients (email, meetings, messaging)?
How often will we check in?
How do you explain financial information to non‑financial business owners?
Pay attention to whether their explanations feel clear, patient, and respectful.
Proactivity & Support
To assess how hands‑on they are:
Will you alert me if something looks off in my finances?
How do you handle client questions between reporting periods?
What does a successful client relationship look like to you?
If you value collaboration and education, a purely transactional bookkeeper may not be the right fit, and that’s okay.
Values & Working Style
You can gently explore alignment by asking:
What do you enjoy most about bookkeeping?
What types of clients do you work best with?
How do you handle deadlines and time‑sensitive requests?
Often, how someone answers tells you more than the answer itself.
Step 4: Determine Process Fit (This Is Where Many Mismatches Happen)
Even a great bookkeeper can be a poor fit if your workflows don’t align.
Onboarding & Systems
Ask:
What does your onboarding process look like?
What will you need from me to get started?
How long does it typically take to get fully up and running?
A clear, structured onboarding process is a strong indicator of professionalism.
Your Role vs. Their Role
Clarify responsibilities:
What tasks do you expect me to handle?
What tasks will you fully manage?
How do you handle missing information or delayed documents?
This helps you understand whether their process matches your capacity and working style.
Tools & Workflow
Important questions include:
What tools or platforms do you require clients to use?
How do you collect documents and receipts?
How do you deliver reports, and how often?
If their systems feel overly rigid—or too loose—it’s worth pausing to consider long‑term compatibility.
Step 5: Talk About Growth & the Future
Your business won’t stay the same, and your bookkeeper should be able to grow with you, or clearly tell you when it’s time to bring in additional support.
Ask:
How do you support clients as their businesses grow?
When do you typically recommend bringing in a CPA or fractional CFO?
How do you adjust processes as transaction volume increases?
You want someone who sees the bigger picture, not just the current month.
Step 6: Trust the Interview and Your Instincts
After the interview, reflect:
Did I feel heard and understood?
Did they ask thoughtful questions about my business?
Do I feel more clarity—or more confusion—after talking with them?
The right bookkeeper should leave you feeling supported, informed, and confident, not intimidated or rushed.
Final Thoughts
Interviewing a bookkeeper is about more than verifying credentials; it’s about finding alignment in skills, personality, and process. Taking the time to ask the right questions upfront can save you months (or years) of frustration and help you build a financial foundation that truly supports your business.
A great bookkeeper doesn’t just keep your books clean; they help you breathe easier and make better decisions.
